The Nord Stream case: Croatia faces a test of justice

Nov 20, 2026 | POINT OF VIEW, NEWSLETTER

By Oleksandr Levchenko

Despite Russia’s brutal aggression against Ukraine, some Ukrainian nationals in various European countries are facing criminal prosecution over alleged activities targeting Russian energy infrastructure. One of the most prominent cases involving the Republic of Croatia concerns Ukrainian citizen Volodymyr Zhuravlov, who has been held in pretrial detention in Pula since August 2026 under a European Arrest Warrant issued by Germany. He is suspected of involvement in the sabotage of the Nord Stream gas pipelines. The question of his surrender to Germany is currently under appeal before the High Criminal Court of the Republic of Croatia.

In 2025, a Polish court refused to extradite him to Germany, considering the case within the broader context of Ukraine’s right to defend itself against Russian aggression. This is precisely why European judicial systems must pay particular attention to the circumstances of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. A formalistic and excessively restrictive application of legal procedures should not lead to decisions that contradict fundamental principles of justice and disregard the right of Ukraine, as a state subjected to armed attack, to self-defence.

At the same time, German judicial authorities are pursuing criminal proceedings against a Ukrainian national over an alleged offence connected to damage to pipelines that for years held considerable strategic importance for Russia. It is therefore legitimate to ask whether all the circumstances of the war, the nature of the targeted infrastructure and the relevant provisions of international humanitarian law have been sufficiently considered in this case.

Damage to privately owned economic infrastructure during an armed conflict does not, in itself, automatically constitute a war crime. The crucial questions are the legal status of the specific facility, whether it served a military purpose or otherwise made an effective contribution to military operations, and whether the rules of international humanitarian law were respected in the course of the attack. According to publicly available information, these were among the circumstances examined by the Polish court when it decided to refuse Mr Zhuravlov’s extradition to Germany.

It should also be recalled that the Nord Stream pipelines were not operational at the time they were damaged. Russia had previously suspended gas supplies to its Western partners, seeking to pressure them into abandoning military assistance to Ukraine and accepting new Russian payment conditions and substantially higher gas prices. Western countries rejected those conditions and secured the necessary gas supplies from alternative sources, including Norway, Qatar and the United States. Consequently, the Nord Stream pipelines remained out of operation, with no active deliveries and no clear prospect of resuming the previous arrangements.

I have neither the intention nor the ability to prejudge any judicial decision. However, I sincerely hope that the Croatian judiciary will carefully consider all the arguments presented by the defence, as well as the decision of the Polish court, which previously refused to extradite Mr Zhuravlov to Germany.

It is worth recalling that in October 2025, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk made it clear that Europe’s problem was not that Nord Stream had been blown up, but that it had been built in the first place. He also emphasised that prosecuting and extraditing Volodymyr Zhuravlov to Germany would not serve the interests of justice, and explicitly welcomed the Polish court’s decision to refuse his extradition.

Beyond the legal framework, the role of Gazprom is particularly concerning. The company appears to be seeking to influence the German judicial approach to this case and encourage the classification of the incident as a war crime, although the legal circumstances surrounding such a classification remain the subject of serious debate.

At the same time, Gazprom finances at least three Russian private military companies whose members have participated in numerous war crimes against Ukrainian civilians in territories of Ukraine temporarily occupied by Russian forces.

Meanwhile, Kyiv and other major Ukrainian cities are subjected to massive Russian missile and drone attacks on a daily basis. These attacks include numerous documented cases of serious violations of international humanitarian law and war crimes that still await appropriate judicial prosecution.

It is therefore deeply troubling that the question of criminal responsibility for a war crime is being raised in the Zhuravlov case, while serious questions also remain concerning Gazprom’s own responsibility for providing financial support to structures involved in Russian aggression and crimes against the Ukrainian population.

Particularly concerning is the fact that Zhuravlov was arrested almost three months ago and has spent this entire period in pretrial detention in Pula, awaiting a final decision on his fate.

This situation restricts his ability to participate actively in preparing his defence while at liberty and to consult freely with his lawyers. It should not be forgotten that pretrial detention is the most restrictive measure available under the legal system against a person whose guilt has not yet been established.

It is a measure that may also be applied to suspects accused of the most serious criminal offences, but in any democratic society it should remain a last resort. Its use is justified only when the objectives of the proceedings cannot be achieved through a less restrictive measure.

It is therefore difficult to understand why a man such as Zhuravlov, who is suspected under a European Arrest Warrant of actions directed against the strategic interests of a state that has committed aggression against his homeland, has been subjected to such a measure for almost three months.

This is all the more difficult to justify when less restrictive measures are available that could ensure his continued availability to the Croatian judicial authorities until a final decision is reached.

I do not wish in any way to prejudge the decision of the High Criminal Court of the Republic of Croatia. Nevertheless, I have confidence in the strength of the legal arguments presented by the experienced Croatian lawyers engaged by Zhuravlov.

I sincerely hope that the Croatian judiciary will take into account all the specific circumstances of this case and that Croatia will not allow his extradition to Germany.

From a human perspective, I find it difficult to understand how Poland could refuse to extradite Zhuravlov to Germany, while Croatia, a country that has itself experienced the horrors of war and understands so well what it means to defend one’s homeland against an aggressor, has so far taken a different approach.

The Croatian people may understand better than many other European nations what Ukraine is experiencing today and what it means to fight for the freedom and survival of one’s own state.

That is precisely why I believe that Croatia will ultimately demonstrate the same level of understanding, determination and commitment to justice that Poland has shown.

Truth Matters. Democracy Depends on It