● Dr J Scott Younger
International Chancellor of the President University,
Honorary Senior Research Fellow of the Glasgow University
and member of IFIMES Advisory Board
Source: Mailchi
Putin’s War – 3
Putin’s war is in its 4th week and no end in sight, although the protagonists have agreed to talk again. Meanwhile, the people flee the country to safety, the count being over 3.0 million to date, with Poland generously opening their country to more than half the number. Sanctions are getting heavier, the oligarchs are being pursued more rigorously for their ill-gotten gains, but it is said that Vladimir Putin himself is worth $200 billion, with a significant amount of this probably in a more stable currency than the rouble. Whatever, he personally is cushioned from the pain he inflicts on his own people as well as the Ukrainians, whose country he is devastating because they won’t behave as he tells them. The Russian people hear largely what he wants them to hear through State-controlled outlets, because he has shut down all the free media outlets, except what the more tech-savvy, generally younger people can obtain through their mobiles. Shades of ‘1984’. It is not so long since the nearby East European countries can easily forget the stultifying hand of the Soviet era from which even some Russian people are trying to flee.
Diplomatic channels remain open – just – but there is no change at the moment in the Russian stance. There is concern that the Kremlin will continue parroting their fake Putin view of things, to tell their own people, while starting to step up the war in unpleasant ways as they have done before – chemical weapons. Putin is not worried about the Court of Human Rights; it’s the West’s construction! Meanwhile, the unabated bombing continues with this spreading to other cities, almost to the Ukrainian border with Poland. Putin won’t let up until least of his objectives are met no matter the suffering he causes and despite the Ukrainians resisting valiantly. For the sake of argument let’s say he continues before the sanctions cause him to stop or he is deposed, which will take some time, however. There is the possibility before that of foreign troops, mercenaries, brought in on the Russian side, for example from Belarus, from Syria, where chemical weapons were used previously, and from Africa. The more ruthless the better! Perhaps the war is not going according to plan. One can already predict the Putin line of fake news for the justification of these troops. In this case, it is time the west organize a foreign legion, not beholden to any country flag, to be attached to the Ukrainian armed forces; not attached to NATO. Is this happening?
One can conjecture would Putin have considered Russia being part of the EU as in long days past it considered itself as part of Europe, prior to the days of Lenin? Probably a fanciful idea but there would be no need for NATO should Russia have shown any positive attitude and the current war would not have taken place. Possibly Russia with a forward-thinking leader rather than one looking back.
Putin and the Soviet reminiscences
NATO is an end of WWII construct to counter the threat of Stalin and the large swathes of Europe he took under his control. Rightly, the US led the way out of the mess created by the war, and they did an excellent job. Over the subsequent decades, the numbers finding ways to get out of the Soviet bloc to western Europe were significant, particularly through Berlin and the brain- drain that was taking place.
The people saw the dead hand of communism in everyday life. The Berlin wall put a brake on the East Germans; there was unrest also in other countries, such as Hungary and Czechoslovakia. However, NATO remained a deterrent to any thoughts of communist Soviet expansion and when the USSR gave up in 1989 and acknowledged that they found the empire of the satellite countries of Eastern Europe was no longer economically viable to control, these countries breathed a sigh of relief, albeit they did in different ways. These countries gradually became part of the EU, after they met the economic, political and administrative guidelines that were required, so that the EU became a sizeable bloc. Not surprisingly, Russia still being a perceived threat NATO expanded its brief, taking in the new countries of the EU bloc.
In the 1990s, when glasnost was in the air, one wonders if the leaders of Russia would have been willing to consider a partial relaxation of their view of government and would have been willing to consider a trade agreement with the EU, along the lines of EFTA. Was the EU ready to consider such? Probably not, and then we saw the rise of Putin, his gradually increasing obsessive paranoia with the west, giving rise to the situation which we have today.
NATO is largely controlled by the US military, naturally as they have the size under one government. The military that the US brings to the body outweighs what other EU nations + UK can muster. But there is the difficulty that the US President has a say in the use of US troops and therefore NATO’s issues are always partially dependent on the colour of the domestic political scene and how the president views his strength. With Joseph Biden, his domestic political position is sometimes fragile, depending on the issue and Congress, compounded by his naturally averse nature towards controversial problems. Had we had Donald Trump still as US president, he would be trying to withdraw the US from NATO! In the longer run the EU should look to increasingly stand on its own feet and be less reliant on the US, whose main occupation will be the rise of China and its expansionist aims, not just with its real threat to Taiwan, which could possibly come earlier than the target date of 2025.
And there is the possible effect this war is having on climate change and the distribution of fossil fuels. A growing worry.
About the author:
Dr J Scott Younger, OBE, is a professional civil engineer; he spent 42 years in the Far East undertaking assignments in 10 countries for WB, ADB, UNDP. He published many papers; he was a columnist for Forbes Indonesia and Globe Asia. He served on British & European Chamber boards and was a Vice Chair of Int’l Business Chamber for 17 years. His expertise is infrastructure and sustainable development and he takes an interest in international affairs. He is an International Chancellor of the President University, Indonesia. He is a member of IFIMES Advisory Board. Lived and worked in Thailand from 1978 to 1983 and visited Burma, Bangladesh and Nepal for projects.
The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect IFIMES official position.
Ljubljana/Glasgow, 22 March 2022
Footnotes:
[1] IFIMES – International Institute for Middle East and Balkan Studies, based in Ljubljana, Slovenia, has Special Consultative status at ECOSOC/UN, New York, since 2018.
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr J Scott Younger: Putin’s War – 3 https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/putins-war-3/5016?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Ukrajina 2022: Stvara li se novi i drugačiji svjetski poredak? https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/ukrajina-2022-stvara-li-se-novi-i-drugaciji-svjetski-poredak/5015?
- Link (ENG): Press release • Former Albanian President and Prime Minister Prof. Dr. Sali Berisha Director received Director of IFIMES https://www.ifimes.org/en/press-releases/former-albanian-president-and-prime-minister-prof-dr-sali-berisha-director-received-director-of-ifimes/5013?
- Link (BSH): Saopćenje za javnost • Direktora IFIMES-a primio bivši albanski predsjednik i premijer dr. Sali Berisha https://www.ifimes.org/ba/saopstenja-za-javnost/direktora-ifimes-a-primio-bivsi-albanski-predsjednik-i-premijer-dr-sali-berisha/5012?
- Link (SLO): Sporočilo za javnost • Direktorja IFIMES-a sprejel nekdanji albanski predsednik in premier dr. Sali Berisha https://www.ifimes.org/sl/sporocila-za-javnost/direktorja-ifimes-a-sprejel-nekdanji-albanski-predsednik-in-premier-dr-sali-berisha/5014?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Prof. Dr. Masahiro Matsumura: Ukraine as Biden’s Sacrificed Pawn: A Mismanagement under the Declining U.S. Hegemony https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/ukraine-as-bidens-sacrificed-pawn-a-mismanagement-under-the-declining-us-hegemony/5011?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr J Scott Younger: Putin’s War – 2 https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/putins-war-2/5008?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Dr J Scott Younger: Putinov rat – 2 https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/putinov-rat-2/5009?
- Link (SLO): Analiza ● Dr J Scott Younger: Putinova vojna – 2 https://www.ifimes.org/sl/raziskave/putinova-vojna-2/5010?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Ukraine 2022: A Test for the EU and NATO https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/ukraine-2022-a-test-for-the-eu-and-nato/5005?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Ukrajina 2022: Test za EU i NATO https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/ukrajina-2022-test-za-eu-i-nato/5006?
- Link (SLO): Analiza ● Ukrajina 2022: Test za EU in Nato https://www.ifimes.org/sl/raziskave/ukrajina-2022-test-za-eu-in-nato/5007?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2022 Albania: “House of Freedom” vs. Drug cartel https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2022-albania-house-of-freedom-vs-drug-cartel/5003?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Albanija 2022: “Kuća slobode” protiv narko kartela https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/albanija-2022-kuca-slobode-protiv-narko-kartela/5004?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr J Scott Younger: Putin’s War https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/putins-war/5000?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2022 Elections in Serbia: Yet another attempt of “assassination of Serbia”? https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2022-elections-in-serbia-yet-another-attempt-of-assassination-of-serbia/4999?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Izbori u Srbiji 2022: Pokušaj ponovnog svojevrsnog “ubijanja Srbije”? https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/izbori-u-srbiji-2022-pokusaj-ponovnog-svojevrsnog-ubijanja-srbije/4997?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Prof. Dr. Masahiro Matsumura: Handling the Ukraine Crisis: A Geopolitical Perspective https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/handling-the-ukraine-crisis-a-geopolitical-perspective/4998?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Ambassador Prof. Dr. Milan Jazbec: After Merkel https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/after-merkel/4996?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr Mohamad Zreik ● China’s Modern Middle East Strategy: Strengthening Partnerships with Iran and Syria https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/chinas-modern-middle-east-strategy-strengthening-partnerships-with-iran-and-syria/4995?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Konstantin Strigunov & Dr. Andrei Manoilo: Color revolution in Kazakhstan 2022 https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/color-revolution-in-kazakhstan-2022/4994?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Prof. Dr. Anis H. Bajrektarevic: Of Health and Nuclear Holocaust (Intentionality, Directionality and Outcome) https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/of-health-and-nuclear-holocaust-intentionality-directionality-and-outcome/4992?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Prof. dr. Anis H. Bajrektarević: Kako izbjeći samouništenje zapada? (Iliti: Doba Isteklih Ljudskih prava) https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/kako-izbjeci-samounistenje-zapada-iliti-doba-isteklih-ljudskih-prava/4993?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr J Scott Younger: IFIMES II: Population and pollution and urbanisation https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/ifimes-ii-population-and-pollution-and-urbanisation/4991?
- Link (ENG): Press release ● Donald J. Johnston the new President of IFIMES Advisory Board https://www.ifimes.org/sl/sporocila-za-javnost/donald-j-johnston-novi-predsednik-svetovalnega-odbora-ifimes-a/4990?
- Link (BSH): Saopćenje za javnost ● Donald J. Johnston novi predsjednik Savjetodavnog odbora IFIMES-a https://www.ifimes.org/sl/sporocila-za-javnost/donald-j-johnston-novi-predsednik-svetovalnega-odbora-ifimes-a/4990?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2022 Bosnia and Herzegovina: From ‘non-paper’ to a crawling war https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2022-bosnia-and-herzegovina-from-non-paper-to-a-crawling-war/4987?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Bosna i Hercegovina 2022: Od ‘non-papera’ do puzajućeg rata https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/bosna-i-hercegovina-2022-od-non-papera-do-puzajuceg-rata/4986?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr Mohamad Zreik ● Lebanon 2022: The Geopolitics of Water Series, Part Three: Water: a commodity or a human right? https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/lebanon-2022-the-geopolitics-of-water-series-part-three-water-a-commodity-or-a-human-right/4985?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr Maria Smotrytska: Decarbonisation and Maritime Transhipment lines: Congested South vs Strategic North https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/decarbonisation-and-maritime-transhipment-lines-congested-south-vs-strategic-north/4984?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2022 Serbia: Referendum – Chance for a turning point in judiciary https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2022-serbia-referendum-chance-for-a-turning-point-in-judiciary/4983?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Srbija 2022: Referendum – šansa za prekretnicu u pravosuđu https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/srbija-2022-referendum-sansa-za-prekretnicu-u-pravosudu/4979?Link (ENG): Press release: Director of IFIMES Zijad Bećirović met with Albanian President Ilir Meta https://www.ifimes.org/en/press-releases/director-of-ifimes-met-with-albanian-president-ilir-meta/4981?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2022 Open Balkan: One voice and an opportunity for all https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2022-open-balkan-one-voice-and-an-opportunity-for-all/4978?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Otvoreni Balkan 2021: Jedan glas i šansa za sve https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/otvoreni-balkan-2021-jedan-glas-i-sansa-za-sve/4973?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr J Scott Younger: From Delta to Omicron – 2021; year in review https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/from-delta-to-omicron-2021-year-in-review/4977?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Juan Martin Gonzalez Cabañas: The triumph of Boric in Chile and the opportunity for a new regionalism https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/the-triumph-of-boric-in-chile-and-the-opportunity-for-a-new-regionalism/4972?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Prof. Dr. Anis H. Bajrektarevic: Unavoidability of Sino-American Rift: History of Strategic Decoupling https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/unavoidability-of-sino-american-rift-history-of-strategic-decoupling/4970?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● Prof. dr. Anis H. Bajrektarević: Post-Corona epilog Sino-Američkog pregrijanog odnosa: Slijedi li promjena igre ili pobjeda? https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/post-corona-epilog-sino-americkog-pregrijanog-odnosa-slijedi-li-promjena-igre-ili-pobjeda/4971?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Dr. Mohamad Zreik ● Lebanon 2021: The Geopolitics of Water Series, Part Two: Water Diplomacy to Deal with the Renaissance Dam Crisis https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/lebanon-2021-the-geopolitics-of-water-series-part-two-water-diplomacy-to-deal-with-the-renaissance-dam-crisis/4969?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● Hellmut Lagos Koller: The Nuclear Weapons Ban Treaty (TPNW): Wishful daydream or Historic milestone? https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/the-nuclear-weapons-ban-treaty-tpnw-wishful-daydream-or-historic-milestone/4968?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● General (Rtd) Corneliu Pivariu: Lebanon – Quo vadis? https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/lebanon-quo-vadis/4967?
- Link (ENG): Analysis ● 2021 Bosnia and Hercegovina: Most brutal attack on truth about Holocaust in XXI century directed and implemented by Milorad Dodik (SNSD) and Dragan Čović (HDZ) https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2021-bosnia-and-hercegovina-most-brutal-attack-on-truth-about-holocaust-in-xxi-century-directed-and-implemented-by-milorad-dodik-snsd-and-dragan-covic-hdz/4966?
- Link (BSH): Analiza ● BiH 2021: Najbrutalniji napad na istinu o Holokaustu u 21. stoljeću u režiji i izvedbi Milorada Dodika (SNSD) i Dragana Čovića (HDZ) https://www.ifimes.org/ba/istrazivanja/bih-2021-najbrutalniji-napad-na-istinu-o-holokaustu-u-21-stoljecu-u-reziji-i-izvedbi-milorada-dodika-snsd-i-dragana-covica-hdz/4963?
- Link (ENG): https://www.europeanperspectives.org/en International scientific journal “European Perspectives”
- Link (ENG): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=645V9eryieI&t=5s (IFIMES presentation film)
Copyright:
Printed texts, analyses, studies, researches, photographies, phono and video reports which are available on this web site and which are provided by the IFIMES International Institute can be transmitted and published by all media and individuals on condition that they use the mark (C) 2021 IFIMES or state the source of the whole text or a part of it. For other information contact: [email protected]
